Growth Hub is now Clandon. Read about our name change.
Comparison
Operations Support vs Hiring Internally
Hiring gives you someone who is yours: fully available, fully directed by you, and building capability you keep. Operations support gives you people faster, with documentation, quality checking and cover behind them, and without the recruitment and management overhead. The right answer depends on whether you are trying to fill a gap or build a capability.
The question
The choice is usually framed as a cost comparison, and cost is the easiest part to work out. The harder questions are about speed, cover, and what happens in two years.
Both options get the work done. What differs is what you are left holding.
Option A: hire internally
Recruit an employee into the role.
Works when
- You want the capability in house permanently, with progression and succession
- The role needs judgement rather than documented execution
- The person needs to be present, in your office, in your culture, in the room
- The work is confidential in a way that suits a smaller circle
Volume is steady and clearly justifies a full role
Costs you
- Time. Months of recruitment before anyone starts, and longer before they are productive
- The full employment cost: salary, employer contributions, recruitment fees, equipment, management time
- A single point of failure. One person on holiday, ill or resigning is a gap with no cover behind it
- The knowledge sits with that person unless somebody makes them document it, which rarely happens
- A capacity ceiling. When the volume grows again you are back at the start
Option B: operations support
An external team or named person doing the work, inside your systems, to your process.
Works when
- The work is operational, documented or documentable, and repeatable
- You need it running in weeks rather than months
Volume is uneven, or likely to grow - Cover matters: you cannot afford the work stopping when one person is away
- You would rather your own people spent their time on something else
Costs you
- Less immediate presence. The people are not in your building and not in your culture in the same way
- It depends on documentation. Undocumented work has to be documented before it can be handed over, which takes effort at the start
- You are not building an internal capability. If that is the goal, this is a stopgap
- Coordination sits with a team lead and an account
- director rather than with you directly, which is efficient but less immediate
How to decide
Four questions about your own firm:
- Are you filling a gap or building a capability? Building points to hiring. Filling points to support.
- How much of it is judgement? If the work is mostly decisions, hire. If it is mostly execution against rules, it can be staffed.
- What happens when that person is away? If the honest answer is that the work stops, cover is worth more than presence.
- What does the volume look like in two years? Flat argues for a hire. Growing or uneven argues for something that scales.
Where we would say hire instead
If the function is one you intend to own and grow, hire for it. A finance function with its own progression, an HR team you are building deliberately, a marketing capability that is part of how you compete: those should be yours. We would be a stopgap, and you would be paying for a stopgap.
The same applies where the role is mostly judgement. A controller, an HR business partner, a head of marketing: hire those. We staff the work underneath them.
And where volume is genuinely small, one part time hire is often simply cheaper than either option. We will say so if we think that is the case.
Where both is the answer
This is the most common outcome and it rarely gets considered. Hire the person who owns the function and exercises the judgement, and staff the processing underneath them.
A financial controller with operations support handling accounts payable, expenses and reconciliations gets more out of the controller than the same budget spent on a controller and an assistant. The hire does what only they can do, and the volume work is done by people whose job it is.
Related resources
The category term, and how it differs from consultancy, temporary staffing and a managed service.
How to tell whether your work needs a team across many workflows or a named person in one role.
A team working across many documented workflows, coordinated through one team lead.
Weighing up a hire?
We will give you a straight answer, including where the answer is that you should hire.

